Set 27 reviews:
Passed Charts:
The Final Song ~ Black Song White Scales (James May) - I haven’t given it a thorough look, but from watching someone else playtest it, it looks very cool and well put. Though, the one hand trills seem very 
, but not enough to warrant a Conditional fix, I think.
Conditional:
Borsalino (ricetoast) - (Focusing on the hardest diff, but the easier one may have these issues as well) This is an amazing song choice for the pack. I’d really like to accept it, since the chart has a lot of potential. However, in its current state, it suffers from overly ghosted notes and dumpy patterns in many sections.
Similar to your previous submissions, it feels like you’re going the extra mile adding extra notes and hybrid-style dump patterns to emphasize certain parts. This is especially true in the second half, where the chart starts to lose its connection to the song and doesn’t hold up well from a technical standpoint. I’d recommend simplifying and cleaning up those sections so they represent the music more accurately and feel more intentional. (The easier difficulty removes some of the ghost notes, which is a step in the right direction toward simplifying and cleaning up sections). If this is fixed, that would be enough for me to pass it.
I also got feedback from Martzi, and she had similar thoughts to mine on her first point:
Feedback from Martzi:
-Both difficulties suffer from quite major ghost note usage that doesn’t quite fit with what this pack is aiming for stylistically. (Especially in the second half)
-The usage of flat jumps/hands to sounds that sound very much so like they should be flams/graces throughout the chart, while a stylistic choice I understand, detracts from the overall feel of the chart, I personally think.
-There’s lots of notes that are 192nd off sync (Sometimes a bit more), its not major, but worth mentioning, its very common throughout the entire chart in both difficulties, but its not enough that people will notice ingame unless they’re going for very high quads.
Love the concept of the chart, I just think it needs polish for the execution. I would comment on everything being 12th/24ths but I can tell that’s intentional quantisation (Most likely to make it harder to acc) instead of keeping it rainbow.
Chiruno no kazu no ue de (Ria) - It looks alright and I’m more or less fine with passing it. I think however there are a bit too many ghosted 16th patterns in the chart and you need to curate them more carefully. Before you jump in and try to fix that, I’m gonna get some more opinions on it.
Rejected:
fahrradsattel (fantasy remix) [TakisEater] - This is a dump chart. This pack is focused on technically accurate / conventional simfiles, and this chart is not suitable for this pack. I encourage you to read the submission rules again and submit something more appropriate.
Also for future submissions, please properly name your folder like this: <song name> (<charter/mapper name>)